Neither the rustic
Wild Life nor the slick AOR flourishes of
Red Rose Speedway earned
Paul McCartney much respect, so he made the self-consciously ambitious
Band on the Run partially to rebuke his critics. On the surface,
Band on the Run appears to be constructed as a song cycle in the vein of
Abbey Road, but subsequent listens reveal that there are only passing similarities between the two albums. Some of this is quite showy, particularly the whimsical mini-suite of the title track and the surging surrealism of “Jet,” but some of the most enduring moments are simpler, like the sunny acoustic "Bluebird" and rocking, rolling "Helen Wheels." Sometimes
McCartney’s whimsy is a little strong, but song for song
Band on the Run is always enjoyable, whether
McCartney is running through “Picasso’s Last Words” or responding to
John Lennon’s “How Do You Sleep” taunts with "Let Me Roll It."
–
Stephen Thomas Erlewine, Rovi